Just to clear 2 things up (one was already addressed):

1. The ONLY PV tartan the DEFINITELY has a "proper kilting selvedge" is going to be the Ireland's National. OCCASIONALLY, we'll get a batch of one tartan or another with a kilting selvedge, but this is NOT common and is NOT a "requestable item". The only time I CAN request it is when I order 250 M of a single tartan to be custom woven (and I pay much more for it).

2. As stated above the only PV tartan to have a "kilting selvedge" is the Ireland's National. Since BOTH the Semi Trad AND Casual are made from PV, this means that they'll BOTH have the "frayed selvedge".

How does it feel on the legs? Honestly, I don't (and I think 99% of the people up here) even feel it. It's not ideal to have the selvedge frayed, but it won't come unravelled and it DOES give it a different look than anyone else.

I'll step back and let the comparison resume...