Alternatives?

[macwilkin]

I would suggest a nice cable-knit/Aran style sweater, especially during this season. I've seen several pipe bands wearing them for "No. 2" dress, and it looks really sharp, INMHO.

And in regards to Robin's question about bonnets in church, it depends: I have seen covers worn in church by pipers and colour parties when "on parade", and I have seen them removed -- best to ask the Padre and see what their preference is, since they're "officer commanding"! :mrgreen:

Cheers,

Todd

[Planopiper]

IMHBAO, Jacobite shirts are costume pieces and look silly in church or anywhere where modern dress is the norm. A vest or waistcoat would be alright and it should be relatively easy to find one. Much easier an cheaper than a kilt jacket. But really, if you just wore a shirt and tie, that should be sufficient. I always wear my bonnet when I'm playing, even in church, even when I'm not playing, if I'm still in the role as piper, i.e. waiting between sets. When my part is finished, though, I would remove the hat.

What's the event? If it's somehow vaugely Scottish in nature, like a Kirkin' O' the Tartan or something, then you should dress the part. But if you're just playing for the music, you really could just skip the kilt and all the paraphenalia. It is possible to play the instrument without dressing different from everybody else.

[Planopiper]

I like the sweater idea, too, if the weather justifies it, but it can get awfully hot playing indoors with a thick, wooly sweater on. A St. Patrick's Day parade in Michigan is one thing. Inside a heated church full of Presbyterians is another.