these are sorta interesting

[KiltedCodeWarrior]

Some of those are definitely out, but others I could see. The Vanetti in black would be no different than a fanny pack (bum bag). I have one from SK in nylon that is just fine for casual use. And the Boho or Westwood fringe would be fine as well. Not sure I like the belt that they are on for a sporran strap though. Too wide. Be interesting to see how the bag is attached to the belt. Might be possible to modify it to use a regular sporran strap.

[Nick]

For the most part, I think they look better on the ladies. But a couple of those I could see being a very nice shooting bag for my Kentucky rifle...

[Riverkilt]

Aye Cloves,

Looks like a mix of Native and Cowboy fashion. Sorta like putting the sporran to the side as I often do on long walks for obvious reasons.

Looks masculine to me...of course, anything I choose to wear is masculine.

Ron

[Big Dave]

Some on them are kind of girly, but some of them I could see as a sporran.

[cloves]

yeah some do look girlier than others....but I think some of that has to do with the context and their color.
Make 'em in buckskin or distressed leather and throw them on a Ren Faire model and they'd prolly look more the part. *shrug*

[Alan H]

I think they'd look great on YOU.

[corbinj]

For you flintlock, black powder guys, this is just like a possibles bag I have. worn by mountain men and women to keep the things you might need right at hand. I have seen hipsters like this one and over the shoulder models.