Kilt Do's and Don'ts

**macwilkin** · 19th February 07, 12:47 PM

Originally Posted by McMurdo

Ok which one is the kilt don't?

Actually, take a look at Morier's painting of a Highland Charge at Culloden, and you'll notice a number of tartans being worn by the same person:

http://ivmoores.com/outlander/cullodenmorier.jpg

You will also see kilts and jackets made from the same tartan during this period; Hugh Cheape's Tartan: the highland habit has a nice illustration of this, if I remember correctly.

Would I wear something like it? Probably not, but it's not necessarily 100% wrong, as Nanook stated -- there is historical prescedent for it.

Regards,

Todd

**Woodsheal** · 19th February 07, 01:05 PM

A combat jump while kilted?! For safety's sake, I'd call it a DON'T:

**RCallan** · 19th February 07, 01:51 PM

Well...if his main cute fails...and the reserve fails....

YOU'VE GOT a KILT!!!! Start flapping those arms!!!

**PiobBear** · 19th February 07, 05:32 PM

Now that's ventilation!

**SnakeEyes** · 20th February 07, 01:34 AM

Do they really jump kilted? You'd think that would be a safety issue.

As for the guy with the matching jacket, I think that looks great.

**Erisianmonkey** · 20th February 07, 01:46 AM

Brings a whole new meaning to wind up your kilt!

**M. A. C. Newsome** · 20th February 07, 05:47 AM

Hey, I actually know the two guys on the left, though I've never seen the one on the right. I think his all-tartan outfit looks sharp! I'm not saying everyone can pull it off, but he does.

I've never seen a tartan PC jacket before, but I have seen tartan Montrose doublets and Sherrifmuir jackets, and these look smashing. Very elegant. Defintely should be reserved for the most formal of occasions. But Todd is correct, there is definitely historic prescident for it.

Oh, and Dread, there is nothing that says not to wear a belt with a PC jacket. It's the vest that determines whether or not to wear a belt. Any time you wear a vest, whether a PC vest or not, you would not want to wear a belt.

Aye,
Matt

**Cawdorian** · 20th February 07, 06:35 AM

We must remember that highland dress as we know it today has evolved over several centuries. What was viewed as correct in 1901 may not be viewed as correct today. This tartan jacket is historically correct, it is a well tailored and obviously custom tailored garment. The tartan on the jacket exactly matches that of the kilt and is obviously made of the same weight tartan.

Matt suggested a book to me a few months ago entitled "The Kilt and How to Wear it" by Stuart Ruaidri Erskine, this book was written in 1901. One chapter discusses the Doublet as he calls it, we know it today as the jacket.

He notes "For great occasions such as balls, dinners, evening reception, audiences at Court, and the like, the tartan doublet is, in my opinion, the best and most picturesque wear. This should be made of the wearer's own clan tartan or livery; and there is no necessity to give it an uncommon shape."

He further notes "By all means cut your evening doublets after ancient models; but pray be careful not to let your shapes neglect the present day. The white shirt and high collar , however much they may offend artistically, should not be banished from our dress. Rather they should be managed in such a manner as, whilst leaving their starched and formal sovereignty intact, yet depreive them of undue prominence."

Toward the end of the chapter he goes into a discourse against black broadcloth jackets as English stuff!

So in my opinion this is a kilt do, it is a mode of highland dress that is very rarely seen today, but it is historically correct according to the standards of the period and Mr. Erskine's 1901 book. It agree with Matt that the outfit is very well done.

The Kirk'n service, as celebrated in the Presbyterian Church commemorates, among other things, the historical roots of the Presbyterian Church in Scotland.

**thescot** · 20th February 07, 06:40 AM

Originally Posted by Bob C.

This may be wrong, but I'm not going to be the guy who tells him so.

In person, that guy is right on. "Yes, sir, nice . . . sporran, laddie."

Anybody bad enough to do that is on one to be trifled with.

**possingk** · 20th February 07, 06:44 AM

Originally Posted by M. A. C. Newsome

Hey, I actually know the two guys on the left, though I've never seen the one on the right. I think his all-tartan outfit looks sharp! I'm not saying everyone can pull it off, but he does.

I've never seen a tartan PC jacket before, but I have seen tartan Montrose doublets and Sherrifmuir jackets, and these look smashing. Very elegant. Defintely should be reserved for the most formal of occasions. But Todd is correct, there is definitely historic prescident for it.

Oh, and Dread, there is nothing that says not to wear a belt with a PC jacket. It's the vest that determines whether or not to wear a belt. Any time you wear a vest, whether a PC vest or not, you would not want to wear a belt.

Aye,
Matt

Matt, I am glad that I am not the only one that didn't think it looked too bad. I don't think I could pull it off (or afford it), but I thought he did well with it.