While I have great respect for the traditional way in which a Prince Charlie is worn, I have seen the 5 button vest/ruche tie combo popping up more and more and I REALLY like it.

Here's a good example:

http://www.highlandstore.com/acatalo...t__Outfit.html

To me it works great for a black tie alternative. It's a fine blending of traditional and modern styles.

Just my two cents.

Shane