Kilt Maker Disappointment

[Archangel]

FWIW, comparing the velcro fastening of my sportkilt to my traditional buckles: the velcro is usually easier but on my fat days (I'm working back down) it can take a couple of goes before the two sides are aligned; the strap is done. The velcro is stiffer and doesn't give when I lean into it: the traditional does.

My understanding is that the new Canadian Armed Forces kilts are velcro (on size fits all = cheaper) and the soldiers are not so keen on them.

I understand that you just wanted one section made velcro, again comparing to other clothes I have (Eddie Bauer wool sweater with velcro) the wool bits/pills/etc block up the velcro and it's a pain to clean. And it no longer holds.

You're right though, if you're paying, it's your choice. Her art, her choice. In a business, she should have explained why those might not be good ideas from either an "engineering" standpoint or her aesthetic sense. Then, while you may still be disappointed, you would not be holding it against her.

Better luck next time.

[CameronTaylor]

James, my only suggestion is (for tonight anyway) contact Steve at Freedom Kilts or any of the fine kiltmaker members here. I'm sure you'll find them accomdating and you'll be satified with your next kilt.
I've made my own as Alan H suggests, live 40 minutes from Sportkilt, and The Tartan Patch last time I checked is about 14 miles away(they're pricey but my Taylor tank is solid as Sears).
Tartan Patch is the only one that had me come in for measuring and such, Steve's guidelines at FK that are easy to follow and the fit is great - he's many miles north and across one international border (sort-of) away.
Good luck with your hunt.

CT - I think my point was they don't have to be close by but I may have missed it ...