I would have to agree with MacDougall a little on the presentation of the choices, but not for the same reason.

The Antartic Tartan was the only tartan show in "Kilt Form" and the rest were just swatches. I think to have an accurate vote you would need to post front and back pictures of actual kilts that have been made in each fabric. Some of those tartans i have never seen in the style of a kilt. I did vote for the Antartic though because i had never seen it before and it was gorgeous.