traditional and modern conflicts

[Nick the DSM]

right, but becasue its not traditional doesnt mean its deuce and not worth calling a kilt. i think pockets on kilts is genius and sometimes it looks great! much better than a heavy and full sporran putting pressure on a certain area. i dont think you need to wear a jacobite shirt or wahtever to wear properly wear a kilt, to me a t shirt is fine!

[Chef]

i agree with james, they ARE like jeans. they wont be the same from then and come in different varieties. utilikilts are the amercanized (butchering for some) version of the kilt, does it mean its not a kilt? no just different.

As I think we have proven many times on the forum yours is not a universal view.