Hands down the semi-traditional from Rocky. I've had acrylic kilts and was grossly dissapointed in the end. Also, I have had that particular kilt, and the "cloth" was fuzzy and blanket-esque. I have 3 casuals from Rocky and I can say that PV fabric is the next best thing to worsted wool. I've also had the pleasure of seeing a semi-traditional model in person and can say it was spectacular.