good line

[bikeolounger]

I am all about the kids learning to sing (or play) on key and in tune. I fully recognize that it takes training, practice, and some more practice (and then some more training).

I also applaud their willingness to show what they can do. I remember doing such things when I was that age, though, and for me at least it was simply part of the normal routine of being in band--we played in public. We didn't much have to concern ourselves with whether people in the audience had perfect pitch. That was the director's job.

And, as I tried to mention, I was impressed at the skill levels shown. "Only cringed a few times" is really quite a compliment from me--I often avoid such things entirely for fear that I wouldn't be able to "uncringe."

[fluter]

the Book don't say "make a beautiful noise", it says, "make a joyful noise",

sing praises lustily unto him with a good courage

[ChromeScholar]

When in danger or in doubt, run in circles, scream and shout...

[Rex_Tremende]

Of course there's so much more to youth music programs than singing or blowing on pitch at the right time that will last a lifetime: performing as part of an ensemble, following a leader, listening to one another, comportment, public performance, exposing oneself to the risk of making mistakes in front of witnesses, surviving mistakes, exceeding beyond one's own known abilities, timing, discipline, dexterity, math...

That's why I smile when I cringe.

Kudos to you for delivering the lesson in diversity, as well.

Regards,
Rex.

[pipesndrumsnun]

Hmmm...maybe you could influence the student performers to be kilted next time!!

[sharpdressedscot]

I can't sing high notes, I can only get bass.

[Archangel]

My ear is getting more training but it depends on the situation. Kids thrust forward in a presentation, I can accept.

The worst (think Billy Connolly, the worst) thing ever with a choir happened at a local restaurant. I'm trying to have a nice meal with the missus and. lo and behold, there is a Sweet Adelines convention, whatever that gathering is called. And they are all having a meal at the same time as us. And every few moments of peace and quiet, somebody starts a song, then they all join in. Warbles and rounds and toilet flushing, help ma kilt.

I just thought that was b. awful and b. rude.

[davedove]

I can sing, but I'm certainly not a singer. However, I am aware of bad notes, awful timing, etc. When I hear my own recordings (strictly home stuff), I am probably my own worst critic.

That being said, because I am aware of my own shortcomings, I tend to be pretty tolerant of others. Well, as long as they're not awful.