There is no accounting for taste, which is what the fashion industry is all about. Just look around you-- it's not confined to wearing the kilt. Robin in his RKilt looks sharp-- it's not everyone's cuppa tea, but it isn't offensive either. Then go to your local mall and look at the guy with three inches of hairy belly showing between his jeans and tee shirt. You be the fashion police.

What I personally object to in any kilt is poor fit, poor workmanship, and the use of a fabric that is unsuitable to the kilt having the proper drape when worn. Sadly, massed produced kilts usually tick two, if not all three, of these boxes.