The general opinion of Jacobite Shirts?

[Birddog]

Cheers Gents,(I say mockingly...I'm at work and can't draw a pint)

Whilst I await the arrival of my US Marines tartan tank, I find myself in need of proper clothing with it. I personally like the look of the Jacobite shirts, and am considering one in navy to go with the tartan. Thought I would poll the opinions here. I'm planning on purchasing lovat green hose, wasn't sure if the shirt should match the hose or not; it would complement the navy blue in the tartan. Dang, trying to be well dressed is hard for someone who is either in uniform or jeans and Harley boots! Obviously, the jacobite shirt would be for less formal occasions. Thanks, mates.

Birddog
Keeper of the Labradors, Defender of the Hounds

[Finn]

The Jacobite isn't for me, but MANY men wear it very well. Go for it!
They come in alot of different colors too.
I prefer banded/collarless (1880's style) or Celtic Croft's Rustic Kilt Shirt w/ 3/4 sleeves.
For a somewhat dressier look with my US Army tartan, I wear an off-white/natural polo. I'm not a dressy guy.

[Tattoo Bradley]

I personally find the Jacobite shirts to be too "costumey." I wouldn't wear one myself.

[McMurdo]

While I have heard the costume comments, I do think that the Jacobite shirt does have it's place, and have seen many members wear them, I have been thinking about getting a few for Scottish Country Dancing as I think the loose fit would be perfect for that, and yes I do think you are right matching the hose and the shirt are always a good thing.

[Livingston]

Jacobite shirts are a personal choice for everyone. For me, I wear them at highland games but usually wear a casual shirt at other times, either polo or button. During winters here, a good sweater will be all you need.

[sharpdressedscot]

They look cool, but I wouldn't wear one for everyday use...or would I?

[Arlen]

I have a 'Jacobite' shirt. I like it and I wear it knowing that it is not historically accurate but that it looks GOOD when worn well.

I would, however, suggest you match the Hose to the Shirt.

[JRB]

I think jacobite shirts are fine for highland games and the like but I'm not sold on them as every day casual clothing. I don't think I'll ever wear one myself.

[mbhandy]

I am with Arlen on the match the shirt to the hose and I wear one but not all the time.

MrBill

[Nick the DSM]

they're cool but not for everyday use.