Glengarry ???

[cavscout]

And we know why, don't we, Jock? They don't keep the heat in or the water out

Really?? I can see the water issue with it having a somewhat flat top that rain would sit on top longer but not as warm? That could be a deal breaker as the heat retention is something I'm looking for this winter.

[haukehaien]

The Glengarry is not a particularly warm hat - it doesn't cover enough of the head to really hold in the heat in cold weather. In winter, I wear a wool Balmoral (or a jeep cap if it's really cold.)