Which kilt- Stillwater Economy or Kiltmart Affordable?

[Ayin McFye]

Since the economy kilt is discontinued, it isn't returnable at all. Not a good sign.

Only a very few have ordered from both companies (I know CDNSushi has). So it's kind of lopsided if everyone responds like, "Oh I haven't ordered from Kiltmart, but I ordered from Stillwater".

I have ordered from both, and my opinion still stands that you'll be much happier with a SWK. Everyone has different tastes though, so who knows. Either way, I don't think you'll be disappointed, I'm just trying to give my opinion on my exp with each. I may buy another kilt from Kiltmart again someday, especially because they are local. But that speaks volumes to me as well. I can do to their shop and buy a kilt, or I can order online at SWK.... and I still prefer to order online if given the choice between the two.

[Panache]

Starshine,

For simplicity's sake I have merged your two threads into one.

I myself am a big fan of Stillwater Kilts and currently own 6 of them (three acrylic Standards and three wool Heavyweights).

Cheers

Jamie