Which kilt- Stillwater Economy or Kiltmart Affordable?

[Starshine]

Starshine,

For simplicity's sake I have merged your two threads into one.

Thanks Jamie, that makes it much easier to find everything.

But if you want to read everything I had to say to compare the two companies, do a General forum search for the keywords: Kiltmart naive review, and you should be able to find it. It was only a few months ago.

It's funny you mention that, yours is one of the first threads I found when I started looking for reviews!

It looks like the overwhelming response is for Stillwater, which I was leaning toward anyway. The only thing that bothers me a bit is the economy being closeout with no returns, but for the price I can probably sell it on eBay if for some reason it doesn't fit quite right. Everyone also has me considering the standard instead, but I think that'll depend on what kind of deals I can get on Black Friday for some of the other "toys" hubby wants (well ok, me too but don't tell). It sounds like I'm definitely safe to wait until after then if I order from Stillwater with their super fast shipping. :mrgreen:

Thanks again for all the help!!!