Prince Charlie alternatives

[Spc. Scott]

I voted Sherrifmuir. I've never worn one but judging from the picture I think that I would be able to do the most with it. It appears to be one of the more comfortable of the choices as well.

But like I've said I've never worn one, so take what you will from that.

Second I really like the look of both the Regulation and Montrose doublets. But again I've never worn one so I can't say for sure.

...now that I've read that whole thing over I don't think I really gave much of an answer to what I'd prefer!

[Cynthia]

This has been an interesting read -- thanks everyone for discussing your thoughts and sharing photos!

[Macman]

Isn't it great to have such choices? I've always liked the Sherrifmuir, and I'm a big fan of Inverness flaps. That said, I personally get more use out of my PC than I would from a Sherrifmuir if I owned one. Still, maybe some day . . .

[JSFMACLJR]

The "regulation" doublet is certainly a good choice, as well. It can be worn with a bow tie, or a jabot (as can be seen in this pic of my father):

[starbkjrus]

I voted for the regulation but would take a Kenmore as well. They both look more comfortable than the Montrose.

With that being said I actually HAVE a Kenmore. It's at home. In my kitchen.

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
With the water and ice through the door option.

[beloitpiper]

Well, I personally like the Sherrifmuir the best. The Kenmore looks a lot like a piper's doublet, and those things are hot. I sweated through many t-shirts while piping in those things. And while I think Montrose doublets looks exceptional (que: McMurdo), they look equally as boiling. So Sherifmuir it is! It look classy and is open in the front for ventilation.

[Jack Daw]

Assuming that I was kidnapped by my college mates, drugged beyond my will, re-dressed by nubile co-eds and forced to wear a jabot (and reminded that 'James Bond' wore one), I would hope to wake up in the Montrose or Kenmore. I like having the belt on the outside. As a matter of fact, I purchased a Canadian-style patrol tunic, which requires an exterior belt, instead of a piper's doublet for some of my military-styled piping gigs.

[McMurdo]

Yes James Bond did wear a Doublet here is a photo

[Bugbear]

And I would gladly wear a lace jabot, but if one is not comfortable with wearing one , I understand.

I'm planning on looking up all the types of attire that can be worn with a jabot.

[Jack Daw]

And I would gladly wear a lace jabot, but if one is not comfortable with wearing one , I understand.

I'm planning on looking up all the types of attire that can be worn with a jabot.

Rub it in!