Being a cheap SOB as well, I wanted a PC quickly, but not spend $$$$$$. I ordered one online (after first checking the return policy), but wasn't happy with the fit. So I went to Kiltmart and found one that fits very well. I took my wife along to give the seal of approval. The advantage of living in PHX with Kiltmart is that you can see and try on before buying. Given that it will not be worn frequently (like at the Burns Dinner next Friday), I believe that it will be very serviceable for a long period of time. When it comes to buying an Argyle, I'll look to invest more.

If you go to the rental places, you will have a point of comparison. I too would be interested in knowing what the going rate for purchase of a used rental. At least in PHX we have some options where we can see the goods first hand.

Where are you located in Phoenix? There are a group of us in the NW Valley that get together regularly at Lis Doon Varna, and other assorted places.