Drum major of inauguration pipe band suspended, quits

[MacMillan of Rathdown]

You framed your question. He framed his answer.
You can ask for what you wish. And label your required answer "simple" if you wish. And interpret rules as you wish.
A respondent is equally entitled to make his own answer. To choose to agree to your "yes or no" request. Or not.

You are, of course, correct. But so far, no one has answered the question that I have posed.

Since you seem to be responding to an exchange between Moski and me, perhaps you could give his posting a quick re-read and then point out to me where I missed his answer to my original question:

"When leading his band in a parade, should any Drum Major wave to a member of the crowd?"