I think it is probably fair to say that although the Gathering itself was a loss maker, its spin off for the Scottish economy has been worth far more. I have certainly been aware of meeting more overseas visitors throughout the season. The recent Muster of the Clans here in the Scottish Borders in September was a spin off from the Edinburgh Gathering, specifically aimed at lowland and border clans and brought a lot of overseas business to our local shops and guest houses at a time of year when the tourist season would normally be winding down. Don't forget Homecoming Scotland 2009 isn't finished yet, we still have the St. Andrews' weekend events to look forward to next month.