I think the lower waistcoat would just look funny. The Sheriffmuir doublet is going to close almost exactly where your tie is and the 3 button waistcoat isn't going to change that. I know you recognize that, but what I think you end up with is your doublet button or hook closure sitting right on top of your tie knot. I think it would look like one of those dresses ladies sometimes wear that have a high neck, but a low neckline, i.e. a peek-a-boo affair. However, I am willing to stand corrected. I suspect Panache ( or someone) has the wardrobe pieces to pose for a quick mock-up. Let's see. I would be interested to see what happens to a sheriffmuir that isn't fastened at all.


If you like the look of a ruche tie, you MIGHT be able to wear THAT with a sheriffmuir and a lower waistcoat.