Battle of the North Inch

[ThistleDown]

As a Clan Chattan historian I can best answer you by saying that your number three is not possible, but that both of your numbers one and two are likely one and the same and therefore probably the answer(s) to your question: who were the clankay and the clanquele?

For more precise answers I lead you well away from Scott's "The Fair Maid...." and on to AM Mackintosh "The Clan Mackintosh and Clan Chattan" (1903), RC MacLagan "The Perth Incident of 1396" (1905), Lachlan Mackintosh "the Kinrara MS" c1670 (to be published in 2010), WH Gregg "Controversial Issues in Scottish History" (1910) and to various other works.