Wow, I really like this. The hunting Cumming (Buchan) tartan has always been one of my favorites.

I'll only chime in to give my agreement with what everyone else says about the boots. I, personally, would have worn a black dress shoe. But, given what (limited) knowledge I have of his personality, I can see why they would be a choice for him, and I suppose they do go with the hair cut. :-)

The only other thing that bothers me about his outfit is his sporran. The main thing that I don't like about it is the asymmetry. I think it's distracting and a bit off putting. But I do like the fact that it is otherwise rather plain. With such a splendid tartan outfit I think a simple sporran is all you need. I think I may have recommended a simple brown muskrat mask sporran. Or he could have stuck with a plain leather day sporran and just worn a more traditional style.

But other than that, I give the outfit two thumbs up!