Those loops of ribbon on the sides.....

[Lallans]

The little loops are for hanging, they just are not useful for hanging- my belief is that they are a survival from ancient times (pre WWII) when kilts weighed less than they do now, ie before 8 yards became the standard for civilians.

But the large loops! I was taught they are for the belt, not the sporran and that the sporran chain or strap is NEVER threaded through them! That's what we do here! Is there a concensus on this suddenly vital issue? Where does one go for the last word???

[longhuntr74]

The little loops are for hanging, they just are not useful for hanging- my belief is that they are a survival from ancient times (pre WWII) when kilts weighed less than they do now, ie before 8 yards became the standard for civilians.

But the large loops! I was taught they are for the belt, not the sporran and that the sporran chain or strap is NEVER threaded through them! That's what we do here! Is there a concensus on this suddenly vital issue? Where does one go for the last word???

Actually, the concensus is the opposite from your understanding. The rear loops are for the sporran strap, not the belt...or so I've learned on this forum. Some use them for both, some for just the sporran strap/chain, and some prefer no loops at all.

Has the OP logged back in yet to explain exactly which loops he was referring too? Lots of great discussion here about both the back loops and the hanging loops...I think we've answered his question either way.

[Lallans]

Actually, the concensus is the opposite from your understanding. The rear loops are for the sporran strap, not the belt...or so I've learned on this forum. Some use them for both, some for just the sporran strap/chain, and some prefer no loops at all.

Has the OP logged back in yet to explain exactly which loops he was referring too? Lots of great discussion here about both the back loops and the hanging loops...I think we've answered his question either way.

I see that major discussion of the belt-vs-sporran-through-the-loops thing is taking place on another string, generally speaking with Scots and Canadians on one side and Americans on the other. Interesting, but clearly there is no right answer until a law gets passed!

[macwilkin]

I see that major discussion of the belt-vs-sporran-through-the-loops thing is taking place on another string, generally speaking with Scots and Canadians on one side and Americans on the other. Interesting, but clearly there is no right answer until a law gets passed!

Not all Americans...I do tire of generalisations by nationality around here at times. :mrgreen:

T.

[Chas]

Not all Americans...I do tire of generalisations by nationality around here at times. :mrgreen:

T.

AMEN to that!

Regards

Chas (an Englishman)

[Lallans]

AMEN to that!

Regards

Chas (an Englishman)

It is what it is. Now tell me: Is an informal survey count on Xmarks comments about the regional use of kilt belt loops racist now? Or just merely bigoted? Or are you guys being ridiculously sensitive I wonder?

[Chas]

It is what it is. Now tell me: Is an informal survey count on Xmarks comments about the regional use of kilt belt loops racist now? Or just merely bigoted? Or are you guys being ridiculously sensitive I wonder?

Oh gosh, that's me exposed - racist, bigoted AND overly sensitive! Thanks for that, Canuck.

Regards

Chas

[macwilkin]

It is what it is. Now tell me: Is an informal survey count on Xmarks comments about the regional use of kilt belt loops racist now? Or just merely bigoted? Or are you guys being ridiculously sensitive I wonder?

No, I just get tired of being lumped into a group purely on where I reside. :mrgreen:

T.