Quote Originally Posted by Tobus View Post
Seconded.

It looks too much like a plain old suit coat to me. Boring. Not 'wrong', necessarily. Just not a great match for the style that accentuates a kilt.
Just not a Highland jacket, in other words, because it gives only a passing nod (its length) to the kilt and accessories its worn with. As for the one worn by Lord Semple in the pics with HRH I'm not sure even the nod was given.