I only have my 1 kilt and can't draw much of a comparison among makers, but my kilt was made by Rock and USA Kilts. I will say, however, that my kilt arrived far sooner than I had ever imagined and fits like a glove. Having the tailored kilt made to my specific needs has spoiled me tremendously. I can't even imagine getting a kilt now in a "standard size".

I will certainly add to the number of kilts, likely from various makers. But I can assure you they will all be made to my size, not off the rack.

Just my 2 cents...

BTW, I think a picture of you in your kilted 501st outfit is missing here