I hear what you're saying Jock but having worn a traditional kilt in a very (very) hot place I can understand the attraction of a light weight cotton-canvas kilt on purely practical grounds. I don't wear one meeself, I have one as part of my collection and I occasionally wear it inside the mansion but I haven't yet ventured out of doors in it and doubt I ever will.

That said I can also appreciate that those with a Scottish connection may still wish to advertise the fact by means of a badge. This seems to fit the purpose adequately. Don't get me wrong. Utility Kilts are not Scottish Kilts but are, all the same, often worn by people with a sense of Scottishness in them.