Too Traditional?

[davidlpope]

I think that cromachs are generally best reserved for Highland Games or for actual hillwalking. I can't imagine myself carrying mine around under other circumstances. They seem to me a very traditional accoutrement and it gives one something to hang on to. I really don't think age is the deciding factor for whether one fancies them or not:







That being said, they are a bit like balmoral bonnets, I guess. Unless at a Highland Games I don't tend to wear mine.

[Tobus]

Context and circumstances. I don't think a walking stick, in and of itself, gives me pause, rather it can be the proverbial straw that breaks the camels back when combined with every other bit of traditional kit one can put into an outfit. Also, it is an odd perception that a walking stick is somehow a required item for THCD, when it really is optional and best suited to situations where it is being useful, instead of just being an accessory.

I'm not sure anyone claimed that it was "somehow a required item for THCD". In fact, I'm pretty sure everyone agrees it is entirely optional.

Yes, context and circumstances should always come into play. But I can't think of any reason why it would not be perfectly appropriate when a fellow is dressed in traditional daywear and attending a Highland Games where he will be (1) outdoors and (2) on his feet all day. One needn't be crossing streams, herding sheep, suffering from old age or disability, or fighting off wolves for a good walking staff to be entirely appropriate. And I'm sure anyone who has ever used one (regardless of the styling) will agree that when you're on your feet all day long, it's more than just for show.

[auld argonian]

Just trying to look good without looking like a temporal anomaly.

Best

AA

[Panache]

Sticks and staffs are different things. A staff is really most appropriate on the trail and a stick appropriate in town. I think that this might be where the problem with Sticks/staffs being perceived as costume might lie. Seeing a fellow in highland attire in an urban setting with a staff might seem a bit affected since staffs are really a rural sort of tool.

I do own a cromach and I think it looks grand with Highland attire. That said I really reserve its use for Highland Games. Jock Scot may disapprove, but I prefer a thicker staff on the trail (such as my "buffalo cromach" or my birding antler handled thumb stick). Their usefulness in bearing my weight and comfort to the hand while walking is more important than their looks.

Another factor about sticks is simply the manner in which they are carried. Those of us who use them often carry them as an extension of ourselves in our stride and when standing. It is easy to spot the fellow that is carrying one just because he thinks it is a fashion accessory. There is a lack of ease about the way they handle them that screams affectation.

I love walking and a nice path always beckons me. I want to see what lies around the next corner. A good pair of shoes, a loyal dog, and a good stick make the journey all the more comfortable and enjoyable.

Cheers

Jamie

[creagdhubh]

I think one needs to exert a tadd of common sense with THCD and the cromach is a useful example.

For some, on some occasions, the cromach is a necessary prop(in a theatrical sense). The Clan Chief on show ,for example.

For some, a cromach is a necessary prop (in a literal sense). A chap with shrapnel in his hip, for example.

For some, on occasion a cromach is a useful tool. Walking across moor and stream, for example.

For some, on occasion the cromach is an unnecessary affectation and therefore of doubtful traditional value.

Judgement and yes, experience, is the key to much of the appropriateness for kilt attire.

Agreed.

[creagdhubh]

I think that cromachs are generally best reserved for Highland Games or for actual hillwalking. I can't imagine myself carrying mine around under other circumstances. They seem to me a very traditional accoutrement and it gives one something to hang on to. I really don't think age is the deciding factor for whether one fancies them or not:







That being said, they are a bit like balmoral bonnets, I guess. Unless at a Highland Games I don't tend to wear mine.

I agree, David.

[davidlpope]

From a related thread... if these gentlemen were carrying cromachs they wouldn't all be walking around with their hands clasped behind their backs!

[Panache]

From a related thread... if these gentlemen were carrying cromachs they wouldn't all be walking around with their hands clasped behind their

David,

There is something to be said for having something to do with your hands!

Another reason to have a staff at a highland games is that it is a comfortable thing to rest on as you watch the athletics and performances when seating isn't available. Our friend Jock Scot once offered us the classic highland gentleman pose of how to properly lean on one's staff and watch the world go by. Any chance of you sharing that one again Jock?

Cheers

Jamie

[Bugbear]

I've seen comments now and then that one has to wear a sgian dubh to wear the kilt traditionally, or that someone doesn't feel fully dressed with out one. For some reason, I don't seem to be able to understand this.

Do you all really notice if someone is not wearing a sgian dubh?

[Jock Scot]

David,

There is something to be said for having something to do with your hands!

Another reason to have a staff at a highland games is that it is a comfortable thing to rest on as you watch the athletics and performances when seating isn't available. Our friend Jock Scot once offered us the classic highland gentleman pose of how to properly lean on one's staff and watch the world go by. Any chance of you sharing that one again Jock?

Cheers

Jamie

Er, I can try Jamie. Any chance of reminding me which one? I lost quite a few pictures a while ago, but if you can give me a clue it would be handy, if I can't find THE one, I might find another for you.