I'm starting to chomp my bit a little for my next traditional kilt purchase, even though it probably won't be until spring. Most likely I'll be going through Scotweb because I've been so pleased with their service and quality.

So I'm thinking Ferguson Weathered or possibly Laing. I've got a Ferguson Modern 8-yd and an Ancient 5-yd for my mother's side, and I really like the weathered colourset; Laing would be from my father's side and it looks nice, but lord that fabric is expensive! In any case, I'm not concerned about the tartan itself right now. I have most of a year to flip-flop my opinion, and I'm sure I will several times

What I was pontificating in particular at this point is the difference between the Balmoral and the Manley Richardson lines. Both my Ferguson kilts are Balmoral, and for the most part I'm very happy with them both. But I keep leaning towards the MR, because one would assume it's higher quality.

Does anyone have experience with both these brands they wouldn't mind sharing?