Who actually OWNS a Scottish hand-sewn?

[Ryan Ross]

Well, I guess I only have one "8 yard hand sewn in Scotland" kilt- it's in modern Hunting Ross (Lochcarron) and has had some major surgery done on it in the States, since a Scottish kilt maker has had their hands on it (it started life as a ten yard monster).

My other two are "4&6 yard hand sewn in North Carolina from Scottish cloth" kilts.

As per the thread's instructions, I'll note a few differences. First off- my preference is for low yardage, though I still do enjoy the look and swing of the 8 yard "tank". Lower yardage means a better balanced garment that is much more comfortable in the waist. I also find the 8 yard much hotter, in the Georgia summer, than the lower yardage kilts; that said, they both seem to keep the cold out equally, in the winter (and before anyone mentions it, yes- I have been kilted up north in the winter, and I have experienced cold before ). Lower yardage kilts are also more economical, as all that tartan yardage costs a pretty penny. I'm also not a fan of the "third buckle" that comes standard on most 8 yarders- while my 8 yard was in the OR, I asked for it to be removed, and have been glad to be rid of it (like the gallbladder, it's not really needed).

Yes, my clear preference is for a nice, heavy weight, low yardage box (or kingussie) pleated affair, with two straps, two belt loops, no fringe on the apron, and no questions asked.

[ardchoille]

All of my kilts (currently 7 with 2 more on the way) are 100% wool, 8 yard, hand-sewn tanks - I don't like the look or feel of any other material. It's easy to own a tank with The Scotland Yard's time pay plan.

4 MacGregor
1 Black Watch
1 Scotland Forever
1 Pride of Scotland

[Ryan Ross]

Does it have to be made with 8 yards, to be considered a proper "tank"?

Might a 4 yarder, hand made from heavy weight worsted, still be one, so long as it's "built like a tank"?

I'm new around here, and not as familiar with the term as I might be.

[ardchoille]

Does it have to be made with 8 yards, to be considered a proper "tank"?

Might a 4 yarder, hand made from heavy weight worsted, still be one, so long as it's "built like a tank"?

I'm new around here, and not as familiar with the term as I might be.

Good question, I'm not sure if yardage matters in the term "tank". Hopefully one of our experts will chime in.

[Ryan Ross]

Good question, I'm not sure if yardage matters in the term "tank". Hopefully one of our experts will chime in.

Ah... well thanks, nonetheless.

I also hope someone comes along and clears up the matter.

[JerseyLawyer]

Per the FAQ:

A 'TANK' is defined as an eight-yard, wool, hand-sewn, traditional kilt. ie., "It's built like a tank." (coined by Jimmy Carbomb c.2005) [Emphasis Added]

Sorry, I was writing briefs all day, hence the emphasis. :P

[Ryan Ross]

Per the FAQ:

A 'TANK' is defined as an eight-yard, wool, hand-sewn, traditional kilt. ie., "It's built like a tank." (coined by Jimmy Carbomb c.2005) [Emphasis Added]

Sorry, I was writing briefs all day, hence the emphasis. :P

Ah, I see... that sounds pretty conclusive. Thank you, kind Sir.

[bchunter]

I own two Stillwater standard kilts, which I wear to work on occasion, but my pride is my 16oz., 8 yard, handsewn in Dunbar from Geoffrey(tailor). I wear it as much as the others combined.

[berserkbishop]

Well, my kilt wouldnt qualify as a "Scottish" handsewn I guess. It is 8 yards of Marton Mills (British Mill) 16oz wool. The entire thing was handsewn by a grand lady of Scottish descent here in the states. To me it is just as good as any "Scottish" kilt.

BB

[RobertParker]

I have two tanks:
1 in Robertson Red - not actually tailored for me; it used to belong to one of the sales people in the shop I bought it from, but they took in the buckles and it fits pretty well

1 in Robertson Modern Hunting - my custom tailored kilt