I Cant Make Up My Mind!!!!

[starbkjrus]

I like #'s 3 & 4.

Isn't number 3 the Caledonia # 155? I've got my eye on that one from USAK. Number 4 looks familiar but I can't place it. Either of those two (IMHO) would make a very nice kilt.

[646guy]

#1 and #2 for me please....just let me know when it's time to come over for measurements

[UmAnOnion]

What we think isn't that important...just select the tartan you like.

After all...you'll wear it, you must like it

Thats the problem!!! I like them all - except #5 which i kinda liked but wasnt all that keen on... just want to get opinions of some of the more experienced kilters on here as to how they think they will turn out...

[Oswulf]

Geez dude, it's easy, take 'em all.

Oswulf

[UmAnOnion]

Geez dude, it's easy, take 'em all.

Oswulf

Oswulf, I like thw way you think but...



Unfortunately I dont have a Hamish sized closet to put them all in (nor do i have the time or $$$ for it either) but if I did...

[McRod]

2 and 3 get my vote.but its up to you, go with whatever you feel is right.

[mddock58]

I like 2,3, & 4.

[davedove]

Personally I like #3, because I like some red in a tartan (see my Avatar). It's just flashier.

[Pleater]

With number 3 you have several attractive but different possibilities for the way the cloth is pleated if to the stripe, plus the sett.

I would suggest getting at least one running length of it - so that you can firstly save time by cutting the kilts as one piece, so there is no need for joins, and secondly make two different kilts by selecting the stripes to pleat to, or doing one to a stripe and one to the sett.

I'd have to get at least two running kilt lengths as I would want to make one pleated with the red stripe centered, one with the white stripe, maybe one to the sett and one to - mmm - I'd have to think about that. The stripe on the red looks a bit weak - but it could be the photo.

Some of the other fabrics look OK, but I think that No. 3 looks to have more going for it than any of the others.