The general opinion of Jacobite Shirts?

[Galb]

I think they look neat and all, but I'd rather just wear a t-shirt or a polo.

[Panache]

Quick visual comparisson

Renaissance Faire Shirt



ECW Heritage Shirt



Of course the Heritage shirt will do OK for a rustic outfit as well (as long as you don't get too hung up on the snaps)




Cheers

Jamie

[DWFII]

Jamie,

Actually you look good in both...maybe it's a matter of "Panache."

On the other hand, I like the Heritage look a little better. I'd like it a whole lot better with a simple button at the throat and at the cuffs. (Might be an opportunity there for the author of the "Heritage.")

Almost beside the point...I also like the fact that your shoes, in the last photo, have no heels. Hollywood...and those who depend on Hollywood...very studiously does not want to hear (avert!! avert!!) that there is absolutely no evidence, pictorial, textual or substantive that prior to the late 16th century any shoe or boot or form of footwear had heels. None. Period. [see June Swann, former curator of the Shoe Museum in NorthHampton England for authoritative confirmation]

[Panache]

I think that from what I have heard the biggest objection to the "jacobite" shirt is that it is not historically authentic...with the cheesy lacing at the throat being the biggest hang-up. For something along the same lines but far more authentic try this shirt:

http://tinyurl.com/552s6u

They even have patterns if you want a particular to match your kilt.

I hate the so-called "jacobite" shirts. They look like 1930's Hollywood pirate shirts! If you want an authentic 18th century shirt with proper long (knee-length) tails, check these out:
http://www.trailhd.com/shirts.html

I took a look at these two shirts and I was surprised to see that my ECW Heritage shirt looks more like those two than a standard "ghillie-Jacobite" shirt does even with the snaps!

Cheers

Jamie

[michaelbeeman]

I picked one up last year to use in a photo shoot for a friend. The shoot didn't happen and I've never worn the shirt. Not really my style.

[12stones]

I'm not too fond of them as I find them costume'y' as well, but wear what you like. I'd agree with matching the shirt and the hose though. Can't wait to see that tank though.

[Jack Daw]

I don't care for them, but if you like the jacobite shirt that is all that matters. But, if you are going for an authentic historical look, this shirt is not accurate.

[keepoffgrass]

I have a couple Jacobite shirts, one in black one in dark green. They're comfortable, light weight, and I personally think they're nice looking with a kilt, even if they are a little bit costumey. My girlfriend however, absolutely loves them, and asks that I wear them more often. So, I guess what ever makes her happy lol

[Mael Coluim]

You might want to consider a Heritage Shirt from Empire Canvas Works.
Check Panache's reveiw here.
You could dye it the color you want.
I have one on the way.

[DWFII]

I think that from what I have heard the biggest objection to the "jacobite" shirt is that it is not historically authentic...with the cheesy lacing at the throat being the biggest hang-up. For something along the same lines but far more authentic try this shirt:

http://tinyurl.com/552s6u

They even have patterns if you want a particular to match your kilt.