Macdonald Tartan found in Drummossie Moor

[McConnell Mor]

I have seen the famous painting of Sir Alexander Macdonald wearing what today is called the Macdonald Lord of the Isles Tartan around 1765, and of course the famous "Macdonald Boys" by Jeramiah Davidson from about 1750. I have heard the stories of the Macdonald of Kingsburgh, Borrodale, and Glenaladale Tartans and their history, but was curious if anyone had actually seen the Macdonald Tartan found in Drummossie Moor. I have heard that it was believed to be of a sett known as Clan Macdonald. Not ever having seen the original tartan I was in fact curious if it matched up to the likes of the Macdonald Modern/ancient etc found today from sources like Wilson's and like the Sobieski Stuart's VS "Clan Raynald". I know that there are those of you out there that might enlighten me. Fill me with your wisdom....

[figheadair]

I have seen the famous painting of Sir Alexander Macdonald wearing what today is called the Macdonald Lord of the Isles Tartan around 1765, and of course the famous "Macdonald Boys" by Jeramiah Davidson from about 1750. I have heard the stories of the Macdonald of Kingsburgh, Borrodale, and Glenaladale Tartans and their history, but was curious if anyone had actually seen the Macdonald Tartan found in Drummossie Moor. I have heard that it was believed to be of a sett known as Clan Macdonald. Not ever having seen the original tartan I was in fact curious if it matched up to the likes of the Macdonald Modern/ancient etc found today from sources like Wilson's and like the Sobieski Stuart's VS "Clan Raynald". I know that there are those of you out there that might enlighten me. Fill me with your wisdom....

I've never heard of any clan tartan being found at Culloden, certainly not the Clan Donald and think this rumour to be baseless. I think it's an apocryphal story probably based on the claim for the origins of Reproduction colours, itself nonesense.

Forum Administrators - suggest that this thread should be moved to the Tartan Place

[David Dubh]

For what it's worth go to the dc dalgleish web site and look at their reproduction tartans and the story that goes along with it. It's very interesting.
Slainte David

[BoldHighlander]

Evan, if you haven't seen it yet, you might find this article written by our own Matt Newsome of interest: Pre-Culloden Tartans.

In it is mentioned a pair of Macdonald tartans, MacDonald of Kingsburg and the MacDonnell of Keppoch.

In this older (closed) thread on the Macdonell Of Keppoch are some computer generated illustrations of various Macdonnell of Keppoch tartans plus a discussion of the Battle of Mulroy (1688).

[figheadair]

In this older (closed) thread on the Macdonell Of Keppoch are some computer generated illustrations of various Macdonnell of Keppoch tartans plus a discussion of the Battle of Mulroy (1688).

I missed that original thread but I would have noted that both versions of this Keppoch sett are probably erroneous. There is a connection with a similar Robertson sett and all are probably based on fragments of the plaid found at Culloden and shown, incorrectly, by D W Stewart in his Old & Rare. I'm looking for more original pieces of this for a paper. See - http://www.xmarksthescot.com/forum/f...ulloden-62702/

[BoldHighlander]

I missed that original thread but I would have noted that both versions of this Keppoch sett are probably erroneous. There is a connection with a similar Robertson sett and all are probably based on fragments of the plaid found at Culloden and shown, incorrectly, by D W Stewart in his Old & Rare. I'm looking for more original pieces of this for a paper. See - http://www.xmarksthescot.com/forum/f...ulloden-62702/

Which tartans? #511 & #879??

[BoldHighlander]

I've never heard of any clan tartan being found at Culloden, certainly not the Clan Donald and think this rumour to be baseless. I think it's an apocryphal story probably based on the claim for the origins of Reproduction colours, itself nonesense.

Peter, this reminds me of an individual I knew years ago who informed me that the Weathered Gordon tartan was based upon fragments dug up at Culloden. This, before I knew better

[McConnell Mor]

Strange because the internet stories abound about the Tartan being dug up was of the Macdonald set?

[McConnell Mor]

Here are a few links....


http://www.dcdalgliesh.co.uk/reproduction.html?start=20



http://www.westcoastkilts.com/kilt-tartan-colours.php

[xman]

As Peter MacDonald deftly points out the perfect absence of any evidence to support DC Dalgleish's claims about the origins of 'Reproduction' colours casts their claim into the pit of Fanciful Invention.

Please see pg. #3 of Tartan Colours found here: http://www.scottishtartans.co.uk/research.htm

Beautiful colours still.