I get that a heavier weight in fabric can equate to a more durable kilt, but from what I have seen of examples, a 16oz fabric is generally coarser as the knit is not as tight as the yarn that makes it is heavier.

But from reading posts here, it seems that many like the 16oz kilt more than that of a 13oz. Is that just because I have not seen better quality fabric, or does it just come down to preference?

I get the feeling from my other thread, that I am going to be pulling my order from one kilt maker in Toronto, and going with John Hart even though it's likely a good 3-4 month wait for my order.

From my limited conversation with John, he recommended a 16oz kilt from House of Edgar. I had originally ordered a 13oz kilt from Strathmore.

Matt.