Personal flair

[Jock Scot]

Would it be possible to make a distinction between the traditional highland approach to kilt attire and a North American approach to traditional highland kilt attire? I think for the most part those in North America who consider themselves traditionalists stay loyal and pay respect to the Scottish highland traditions of kilted attire but given cultural differences, they are bound to show somewhere in our attire. I personally do not see this as a disregard or lack of respect to the highland traditions but an adjustment to our cultural frame of reference. It is still distinctly Scottish with the minor subtle differences that only and experienced highlander kilt wearer would notice. Thoughts?

Choice is a personal matter for each and every one of us and if you want to dress as a clown, then, who am I to comment. Highland Scot, North American, Swede, Martian, will, as you point out, have their interpretations for sure, perhaps encouraged by unhelpful misinformation from many directions and that is why I use the expression of "dressing to best effect" which is rather less controversial internationally speaking, I think. Nevertheless, there is no escaping the fact that the traditional kilt and its attire, is recognised the world over as Highland Scots attire, particularly in the traditional form, so no, I don't feel personally that there is any latitude, apart from climate considerations, for rather excessive traditional kilt attire adjustments that some here are suggesting.

Whilst I may not like some people's choices, if someone claims that they want to dress in the kilt as they please, then that is their choice and that, I respect. If they call their version "traditional" then I may, or may not, air my views.