Well, I just got my father this Sgian Dubh for Father's day

and I'm pretty well pleased with the quality and price. It's a very well made formal Sgian.

Now, I'm considering getting it for my wedding but I'm not sure. My kilt will be the Macdonald of the isles red as seen here...

Should I go, instead, for this one with the black stone?

They are both absolutely gorgeous, but I'd like the nicest, most formal one for my wedding and my opinion really is split between the two.