Quote Originally Posted by Moosedog View Post
Just my opinion,

Based on the ones I've seen (including the pictures in this post) I like them better with an argyll+vest--I think the higher-necked vest allows for the a bit of color and the scrunchy effect without taking the eye away from the kilt's beauty. The PC vest ( sorry McMurdo, as always you look quite dashing) allows too much ruche to show for my taste.

Moosedog
Definitely agree. I couldn't pull it off with a PC and three button vest (bow tie for me there) but with an Argyll and 5 button waistcoat I prefer them. I have two (thank you again McMurdo) and wear them whenever the occasion arises.