Quote Originally Posted by Swampthing View Post
I suppose that is true for the mindset of most in the modern world, a new tradition of clan tartans is real, in a sense.
But it stems from misconceptions and myths, and therefore, though it may be a tradition, it's one for the ill-informed.

I also suppose that it was not actually a tradition in the old days, but rather, a trend and consequently, a custom.

You really should have a look at albanach.org, scottishtartans.org, kiltmaker.blogspot.com, or simply speak to Mr. Matthew A.C. Newsome, of the Scottish tartans museum, he's very good with that stuff.

Please note that I have nothing against you, or am arguing with you, it's just that this notion of clan tartans being ancient and all simply isn't true.
Matt will be the first to tell you, though, that even though the concept of clan tartans does not have an ancient pedigree, enough time has passed to make it a de facto tradition, and one to be respected. While I agree 100% that clan tartans have not been handed down through the mists of antiquity, to simply dismiss someone having pride in their clan's tartan as "ill-informed" just doesn't seem cricket. If it's not for you, then great. For some, there is very powerful symbolism behind their tartans.

Matt is a member and frequent contributor here, btw. I'm also the proud owner of one of his kilts in the Iowa tartan, which although designed in 2003, has very special significance for me, as it honours my family who immigrated there.

regards,

Todd