I wasn't a huge fan of the second one from the pictures of the swatches. However after seeing Matt's pictures I have changed my mind. I like the first one, but agree it would have to be suited to one's coloring. The second one doesn't look nearly as busy in Matt's picture. Both are good chooses in my opinion. I would say it comes down to if the first on suits your coloring or not. If it does, go with it. If not, go with the second one.