Thanks, CMcG, for a' that assembling and posting. And for the link to the earlier thread. I like the idea of facings on the lapels and cuffs- wooly or velvet MIGHT just work in the daytime, but shiny or silky would pretty much scream evening wear, I think. A big advantage of solid color facings ( black, navy, even green) would be to point out the tartan a little more by contrast. Since I am planning to work from an already constructed jacket, the pocket flaps might become an issue, but again, using solid fabric to replace them is a good solution.

I dearly love the frogging and braid on the 18th century (?) doublet, but I think that may be too much even for me- and nigh impossible to work from a pre-existing blazer.

I will put in a small, but related plug for Hothir Ethelnor, author and model of the lovely bias doublet in the other thread. I believe he is now helping Josh (NorCal Piper) make doublets over at Skye Highland Outfitters. Josh is doing a little website maintenance at the moment, but the last time I looked, H-E's tartan creations were available to order in PV for remarkably low prices.

I recognize and respect the widely (and wisely) held opinion that a venture such as this is really the province of experienced tailors who will start from scratch, but some of us are born to rush in where angels fear to tread. If this jacket ever gets off the drawing board, I will be sure to post pics.

Thanks everybody, so far and yet to come...