Too Traditional?

[davidlpope]

I'm wondering if the title to this thread might not be better phrased as "Are we simulacrums?" (i.e. are we creating a perfect, yet inauthentic, replica of a Highland gentleman for the sole purpose of attending a Highland Games here in the United States?)

Thus the balmoral, clan plant badge, cromach, sgian dubh, garters, etc...

The practical purpose of any one of these items is likely better served by some more practical means/device.

But, to misquote Miss Bingley:

"Indeed, much more practical,

but rather less like a Highland Games."

Just food for thought, as I am determined to see a lion dance video...