Non tartan kilts have a long history,, so that's not it.
Short yardage has a long history so that's not it.
To me it's overall appearance, not wearing a sporran is a major fault, as is length below the knee or way add those two together and I doubt it's a gentlemans kilt.
On a lady with with no sporran, it's a kilted skirt, what ever the length.
Bookmarks