Well, I actually just bought a second kilt yesterday. Used, and a really good price.
Unfortunately, I appear to have gotten the size wrong again.

First, my size as I understand
36.5”- Pant size (waist)
38.25”- Kilt size (belly button)
23.5”- Length (belly button to floor while kneeling)


Used, but in great shape. Supposedly purchased in Edinburgh
Brand- The Kilt
I believe it called a casual kilt
Rayon/Acetate
Black Watch
Size 38-40
Length 24
Closing method- One strap on each side at the top of the kilt

If I put this kilt on (top of kilt 1” above belly button), it is a hair long, but acceptable. But with the straps pulled all the way closed (one strap each side) the kilt is to big. With a light hop, it falls off.
——————

My other, kilt ordered from the States
Brand- UTKilt
Standard Utility Kilt
Polyviscose material
Highland Gray
Size 40 (when ordered, my waist was a hair over 39”)
Length 22”
Closing method- double snaps on each side with two buckles on the right at the waist (3-4” from top)

With this kilt on (top of kilt at belly button), it just reaches the top of my knees. With the straps pulled all the way closed, it will stay up as long as I’m not overly active. ie…normal walking around the house.
—————————-

In my mind, both of these kilts should fit at the tightest setting. The Utility kilt I can get away with, and the belt helps but is more accessory than requirement. The Black Watch one however, I have to wear a belt, and it scrunches up the waist a little.

I always believed, if it’s a little large you can wear a belt. But if it’s two small your screwed. From the measurements above, do you believe I should have gone to the lower size? Does the style of kilt have a large effect on fitting?

I will probably end up reselling the Black Watch kilt. I’ll give it a wash, and wear it for a day to see how it feels, but it will likely move on to a new home.

Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

Darrin