Vest length question

[Father Bill]

As regards sporran height, which of course interacts with vest length: I wear my sporran where it's most comfortable. What a concept!

In my case, because of my body shape, it's comfortable a wee smidgen higher than many might wear theirs - not visually out of place or visually unusual, but comfortable. A sporran is not a sports protector.

[Kitfoxdave]

Folks, I appreciate your insights and feedback. Thanks so much!

[Panache]

As regards sporran height, which of course interacts with vest length: I wear my sporran where it's most comfortable. What a concept!

In my case, because of my body shape, it's comfortable a wee smidgen higher than many might wear theirs - not visually out of place or visually unusual, but comfortable. A sporran is not a sports protector.

Which makes perfect sense considering that body types vary. The length of your legs and torso and the width of your girth are all factors that will determine what is most comfortable and looks best.

Cheers

Jamie

[Allan Thomson]

Just an aside, I am definitely opposed to the 'modern' practice of wearing kilts low, but re waistcoat length it's not exactly correct to say that waistcoat lengths getting longer is a departure from traditional highland styles - there's plenty of images that illustrated longer waistcoat lengths were also acceptable - indeed quiet a few that illustrated at certain periods waistcoats typically worn by civilian Highlanders were actually longer than the jackets worn over the top.

[OC Richard]

Just an aside, I am definitely opposed to the 'modern' practice of wearing kilts low, but re waistcoat length it's not exactly correct to say that waistcoat lengths getting longer is a departure from traditional highland styles - there's plenty of images that illustrated longer waistcoat lengths were also acceptable - indeed quiet a few that illustrated at certain periods waistcoats typically worn by civilian Highlanders were actually longer than the jackets worn over the top.

What period?

For sure in the 18th century waistcoats were long, though once again the Highland ones were rather shorter than their English counterparts.

I was talking about the period after modern-style jackets and waistcoats appeared, roughly the 1840s.

I looked though a pile of old photos and paintings and I did find one with a waistcoat longer than the jacket, a child's outfit from the mid-18th century.



The adult's outfits were showing this

[Jock Scot]

What period?

For sure in the 18th century waistcoats were long, though once again the Highland ones were rather shorter than their English counterparts.

I was talking about the period after modern-style jackets and waistcoats appeared, roughly the 1840s.

I looked though a pile of old photos and paintings and I did find one with a waistcoat longer than the jacket, a child's outfit from the mid-18th century.



The adult's outfits were showing this

I think we do need to remember that hand-me-downs were and still are, to an extent, an issue of note for much of Scotland's attire, so we do need to be careful when making attire judgements from pictures and paintings. Yes of course, the tailored look for an individual, with their new super dooper outfit that fits to a T, but, care needs to be taken when observing these wonderful outfits.

[Kitfoxdave]

Interesting how high up the sporran is worn in the second picture that Jock posted... with strap going through the back of sporran and over the waistcoat...

Very different from current "tradition"....

Jock, thanks for these references and sharing information...