-
11th June 24, 10:20 AM
#1
 Originally Posted by Troglodyte
The author writes that, at a lecture given on the subject, his authority and knowledge was challenged by one of the audience with the statement that white in tartan signifies it was worn at the Battle of Culloden. Why did he not know?
So only Highland Dancers were aloud to fight/dance at the battle? lol
Clan Logan Representative of Ontario
https://www.instagram.com/clanlogan_ontario_canada/ (that's where i post my blogs)
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCVgTGPvWpU7cAv4KJ4cWRpQ
-
The Following User Says 'Aye' to Patty Logan For This Useful Post:
-
12th June 24, 11:11 AM
#2
 Originally Posted by Patty Logan
So only Highland Dancers were allowed to fight/dance at the battle?
Or perhaps they're the only ones who keep up the tradition of authentic Culloden-worn tartans.
Here they are https://www.inglesbuchan.com/highland-dance-tartans/
Proud Mountaineer from the Highlands of West Virginia; son of the Revolution and Civil War; first Europeans on the Guyandotte
-
-
13th June 24, 09:27 AM
#3
When I first joined my local St. Andrews society as a teen, there was a gentleman who everyone thought of as the kilt expert. Several people told me to see him about what to wear. Some of his wisdom was about the colors in one's tartan. I can only remember two, both of which turned out to be myths. They were a gold stripe represented loyalty to the (English) crown and a white stripe represented Christianity as opposed to pagan religious affiliation of an entire clan.
-
The Following User Says 'Aye' to AFS1970 For This Useful Post:
-
13th June 24, 09:33 AM
#4
 Originally Posted by AFS1970
When I first joined my local St. Andrews society as a teen, there was a gentleman who everyone thought of as the kilt expert. Several people told me to see him about what to wear. Some of his wisdom was about the colors in one's tartan. I can only remember two, both of which turned out to be myths. They were a gold stripe represented loyalty to the (English) crown and a white stripe represented Christianity as opposed to pagan religious affiliation of an entire clan.
Oh, for an "eye-roll" emoji!
Rev'd Father Bill White: Mostly retired Parish Priest & former Elementary Headmaster. Lover of God, dogs, most people, joy, tradition, humour & clarity. Legion Padre, theologian, teacher, philosopher, linguist, encourager of hearts & souls & a firm believer in dignity, decency, & duty. A proud Canadian Sinclair with solid Welsh and other heritage.
-
The Following User Says 'Aye' to Father Bill For This Useful Post:
-
15th June 24, 02:45 AM
#5
 Originally Posted by AFS1970
I can only remember two, both of which turned out to be myths.
They were a gold stripe represented loyalty to the (English) crown and a white stripe represented Christianity as opposed to pagan religious affiliation of an entire clan.
Peter more for your list!!
It would be instructive for all tartan aficionados for somebody to go colour-by-colour with this guy and discover the hidden meaning of each.
And take notes so it can be preserved for posterity.
Proud Mountaineer from the Highlands of West Virginia; son of the Revolution and Civil War; first Europeans on the Guyandotte
-
The Following 2 Users say 'Aye' to OC Richard For This Useful Post:
-
15th June 24, 07:51 AM
#6
[QUOTE=OC Richard;1407930It would be instructive for all tartan aficionados for somebody to go colour-by-colour...[/QUOTE]
I think we are going to need need some fairly complex Venn diagrams...
This little gem is from the BBC - Today, the colours identify religion as red and green tartans represent Catholics and the blue represents Protestants. The divide is important in Scotland as one can identify people's religion by what colour tartan is worn.
Last edited by Tomo; 15th June 24 at 07:57 AM.
-
-
15th June 24, 10:23 AM
#7
" Rules are for the guidance of wise men and the adherence of idle minds and minor tyrants". Field Marshal Lord Slim.
-
The Following 2 Users say 'Aye' to Jock Scot For This Useful Post:
-
15th June 24, 01:57 PM
#8
 Originally Posted by Tomo
I think we are going to need need some fairly complex Venn diagrams...
This little gem is from the BBC - Today, the colours identify religion as red and green tartans represent Catholics and the blue represents Protestants. The divide is important in Scotland as one can identify people's religion by what colour tartan is worn.
Now I must clean coffee off my computer monitor.  Such silliness.
"Cuimhnich air na daoine o'n d'thaining thu"
Remember the men from whom you are descended.
-
-
15th June 24, 11:45 PM
#9
After visiting Scotland, I found the tartan pattern very interesting and discovered that there is a lot of history, meaning and importance to it. There are many different tartan designs representing different clans and names; there is a pattern for most Scottish names as well as my own. Red, green, blue and yellow tartans are the most common. History has it; the meaning of the colours has changed since the 19th century. It's said that red tartan was worn in battle so blood would not show, green resembled the forest, blue symbolising lakes and rivers and yellow resembling crops. Today, the colours identify religion as red and green tartans represent Catholics and the blue represents Protestants. The divide is important in Scotland as one can identify people's religion by what colour tartan is worn. Ultimately the tartan kilt is a universal symbol of "scottishness" and represents that culture and all its history.
This is what the BBC has on their website - contributed by Jennifer Mcpartlin.
No mention of who, or what she is, or her authority to pronounce on tartan in this way but, if the information on the BBC website is anything to go by, it now forms part of the BBC Schools Lesson Plan, BBC Archive Chronicle, BBC History, and BBC Culture 24 networks.
As a professional career of more than 45 years in journalism. I can say with a good deal of personal experience that the editorial standard at the BBC has always been low, subjective at an individual level and considered something of a joke in the industry. But this beggars belief.
How many youngsters will have been given this kind of nonsense as gospel fact in their history lessons, and thought it unquestionably true because it comes from the BBC? And it's on the internet, so how could it be otherwise..?
I can well imagine the day will soon come (if it has not already arrived) when the lads at the Scottish Tartans Authority will be told they are wrong, and know nothing because the BBC says...
But wait!
I know what it is. I've died, haven't I..? And I'm in purgatory, and having to suffer this kind of torment is how my sins are being expiated.
Boy, I must have been a bad 'un...
-
-
17th June 24, 09:24 AM
#10
 Originally Posted by Tomo
I think we are going to need need some fairly complex Venn diagrams...
This little gem is from the BBC - Today, the colours identify religion as red and green tartans represent Catholics and the blue represents Protestants. The divide is important in Scotland as one can identify people's religion by what colour tartan is worn.
Wow. I'm writing all this nonsense down, we're getting a fairly sizeable list already. Keep them coming!!
Now, colours do have liturgical meaning, but Catholics and Protestants use the same colours to signify the same thing: the seasons of the church calendar.

Isle of Skye tartan, being largely green and purple, fits nicely.
Last edited by OC Richard; 17th June 24 at 09:30 AM.
Proud Mountaineer from the Highlands of West Virginia; son of the Revolution and Civil War; first Europeans on the Guyandotte
-
The Following User Says 'Aye' to OC Richard For This Useful Post:
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|
|
Bookmarks