It's a simple answer really. Get one of the UtiliKilts Workman's models. They take a beating like nothing else, and also allow you to store everything in the pockets. In the winter, it will be plenty warm after a game (trust me on that one). In the summer, it's still wearable since the pleats aren't too numerous, and they're "airry".

I have a kilt for the Penguins and Steelers jerseys that I have... Loud MacLeod works well.

For the Flyers, I just wear an all-black kilt with the jerseys. Anything else is just too busy since our jerseys are pretty ornate. It went over real well on opening night!

If your budget is not in line with a UtiliKilt, there's always an AmeriKilt or a Pittsburgh Kilt. I don't know enough about Freedom Kilts, or have even seen one for that matter. I would assume that they would work well for this too.