Decisions, decisions.

[auld argonian]

I dunno...the Gordon one looks pretty neat...I already have a Gordon in a wool blend (a Stillwater "special", as a matter of fact) but it's pleated to the sett and the Gordon Economy is pleated to the stripe...and it would be a knockaround kilt.

Funny about the Wallace, though, a buddy of mine is of the opinion that if he were to get a kilt, it would have to be a RED one so that it would be clear to people that it was, indeed, a KILT and not a SKIRT. Where this guy ever got this idea...?

I have heard that the quality of the Stillwater Eco's has been kicked up a notch...obviously not as cool as the Standards but better than the average economy kilt.

Best

AA

[GreenDragon]

Oh, and by your avatar I should also mention that Rowdy Piper wore the Wallace tartan at least for a little while.

Yes, he did.

[ozmeath]

I'd go with Irish nat or Black Watch but it all depends on yr colouring/what your into as mentioned before. What have you got already? Are you after a contrasting kilt to that? Let me be that cat amongst the pigeons and suggest the saffron! Good luck.

[millar]

suggest the saffron!

The saffron is on my wish list as well.

[Joe Gondek]

my vote is for the BW
I also think Black watch should be in every kilted man's closet

[GreenDragon]

I'd go with Irish nat or Black Watch but it all depends on yr colouring/what your into as mentioned before. What have you got already? Are you after a contrasting kilt to that? Let me be that cat amongst the pigeons and suggest the saffron! Good luck.

This would make Kilt Numero Uno for me.

[Canadian_Kilt]

Acutally if I was to get any kilt from SWK based solely on looks, the Black Stewart gets my vote. I really like the pattern .. but they only come in Standard.

Of the ones you chose, I think I'd go with Black Watch over Wallace. It's a bit more subtle for a first kilt. That's one of the reasons I chose it.

[Colin]

Why not just grab two or even all three. Hey for $45 a kilt, it works out to about $130 for 3 kilts. I have heard better things about the standard than the econo, but the econo looks like a good starter. Based on Cavscout's logic though, why not have a good look at the Leatherneck tartan in the econo.

[cavscout]

Let me be that cat amongst the pigeons and suggest the saffron! Good luck.

Nicely done Erin

"I too am not a bit tamed, I too am untranslatable, I sound my barbaric YAWP over the roofs of the world." - Walt Whitman

[thekiltedmortician]

I like the Black Watch the best, with the Irish National a close second.