Sad times

**beloitpiper** · 20th February 07, 11:59 PM

Not exactly Scots, but still a part of our culture.

http://news.scotsman.com/scotland.cfm?id=276452007

**Pour1Malt** · 21st February 07, 01:55 AM

it is Scots...

a specific dialect o' Scots....

sadly, some folk want tae see Scots an it's dialects die oot....

no ma though... ai'll keep bletherin oan...

**McMurdo** · 21st February 07, 05:13 AM

That is sad news, lets hope they at least get it recorded. P1M you just keep bletherin oan, wouldn't be same if you didn't.

**Jerry** · 21st February 07, 05:52 AM

Definitely, keep on writing in Scots, P1M. I'm sure that others, like myself who have been here since 04 and earlier and thought at first that you were being somewhat of a smart **** would miss it if you stopped now.

**beloitpiper** · 21st February 07, 07:29 AM

Haha, at first I had trouble understanding P1M, but being on this forum has really helped out my Scots. I can read it with no problem now! It really helped during the Burns Supper.

**pdcorlis** · 21st February 07, 08:16 AM

That is a real shame - by the way P1M, if you offer a correspondence course in Scots sign me up!

**starbkjrus** · 21st February 07, 12:51 PM

Originally Posted by beloitpiper

Haha, at first I had trouble understanding P1M, but being on this forum has really helped out my Scots. I can read it with no problem now! It really helped during the Burns Supper.

Aye, if not for reading Robertson's posts all this time I would have been lost at the Burns Supper.

**Dirka Skene** · 21st February 07, 01:15 PM

Fascinating, but sad news. I would love to hear it actually spoken.

**McClef** · 21st February 07, 01:23 PM

I don't think that Scots is in particular danger but some dialects definitely are.

Local ones such as the Cromarty though are surely the responsibility of the locals to preserve in everyday usage. That may sound harsh, and it isn't meant to be by any means, but it cannot be transplanted to another area of Scotland without losing its relevance and possibly without having an effect upon another local dialect.

Having watched a documentary about young offenders at Polmont last week even my reasonably attuned ear was struggling with some of the heavy accents!

None of them were from Cromarty of course. Of course it's important that there is an audible record, but language changes and dialects change with it and it requires a local will to preserve it. If the will isn't there it's fighting a losing battle.

**McClef** · 21st February 07, 05:10 PM

I also note that the Scotsman article so far has nearly 150 comments on the website compared with the four they had before they closed the comments on the kilts!

or what?