Quite the spirited thread with a lot interesting ideas on both sides. I think the "By choice, Not Blood" is a decent motto that doesn't exclude anyone despite what some say, but I don't think we should have it as our motto. "By Choice, Not Blood" alludes to how we all joined X Marks, but nothing about what X Marks is about which is Kilts.I think that our motto should mention something about kilts. Here are a few suggestions that we could translate to latin or gaelic at some point:

In Kilted Fellowship (as someone else suggested)

Fellowship through Kilts or Worldwide Fellowship through Kilts

Freedom from Pants! or Freedom from Bifibrication!


On the funny side:

The Kilted Clan or The Clan that Actually Wears Kilts

Its not a Skirt!

Also can we have a new poll to include some of the other mottos people have suggested?

Finally, relax. There are a few people that seem to be taking things way too serious and/or literal. This is a fun forum. No need to get high blood presure over a motto.