I'm afraid I'm mostly, but not completely, with your friend. I don't like the Utilikilt I have less trouble with the fabric (I do prefer wool though) as I do with the style. I don't think it looks like a kilt, especially with side pockets etc. However I am not completely against pockets in kilts, I think the slash pockets that Steve does at FK are brilliant.

As for the Nightstalker sporran...I'm not crazy about it although I would like to see the one made from leather. Personally I think there are plenty of better sporrans that look more traditional.