Which outfit is "more Scottish?"

[Bob C]

The advice you've gotten here is fine, but I'd go with the Argyll. "Culture Day" is a special event, so why not dress it up a bit? Of course, a tweed Argyll would suit the occasion better than the barathea, but what you've got is what you've got.

I'd skip the flat cap indoors, if you're going with the waistcoat.

[Jock Scot]

The advice you've gotten here is fine, but I'd go with the Argyll. "Culture Day" is a special event, so why not dress it up a bit? Of course, a tweed Argyll would suit the occasion better than the barathea, but what you've got is what you've got.

I'd skip the flat cap indoors, if you're going with the waistcoat.

I mean no offence here, but Bob's answer clearly demonstrates the difference between how I perceive you Americans see things and how us Scots see things. We Scots prefer the low profile "less is more " approach, Bob, batting for the USA, on the other hand likes the more showy approach. Each to their own.

[macwilkin]

I mean no offence here, but Bob's answer clearly demonstrates the difference between how I perceive you Americans see things and how us Scots see things. We Scots prefer the low profile "less is more " approach, Bob, batting for the USA, on the other hand likes the more showy approach. Each to their own.

Of course, not all Americans see things the same way, nor do all Scots, Jock, generally and on this specific topic as well.

One must be careful with generalisations...

Todd

[Jock Scot]

Of course, not all Americans see things the same way, nor do all Scots, Jock, generally and on this specific topic as well.

One must be careful with generalisations...

Todd

Of course you are quite correct Todd , nevertheless after a year and a bit on this website, taking note of the pictures and views aired here, I think that my generalisations are not far from the mark. Be assured that I mean no offence to any one.

[macwilkin]

Of course you are quite correct Todd , nevertheless after a year and a bit on this website, taking note of the pictures and views aired here, I think that my generalisations are not far from the mark. Be assured that I mean no offence to any one.

We're a' Jock Tamson's Bairns...

T.

[Jock Scot]

We're a' Jock Tamson's Bairns...

T.

Aye! It is inevitable, though, that those bairns can and do have differring thoughts on a particular subject. As long as those thoughts are politely voiced and graciously received, no harm should be done.

[Highlander31]

This discussion could be the basis for a lecture on Clockwork John's School's Culture Day. What does it mean to be Scottish? The Scot's obviously have an inside track on this, however, in America we have a view that is filtered by time, distance, and Political Correctness.

Growing up in the '50's and '60's I never imagined I would see a college professor fired for wearing a kilt on "Culture Day." This happened at California's Chico or Davis in the '90's. I can't recall which school right now. I spent several years visiting elementary schools on Tartan Day with an associate to educate the students on Scottish history and how it affected the U.S. (most people don't realize the Declaration of Independence is based in part on the Scottish Declaration of Arbroath which was written in 1320.) We faced opposition from school officials. As one principle stated it was not considered appropriate to present Scottish heritage to the children.

Clockwork John has a great opportunity to educate his students on the contributions the Scots (and those of Scottish heritage) have made not only to the U.S., but to the world.

Have a good Culture Day CJ in whatever you decide to wear with your kilt.

[Bob C]

I mean no offence here, but Bob's answer clearly demonstrates the difference between how I perceive you Americans see things and how us Scots see things. We Scots prefer the low profile "less is more " approach, Bob, batting for the USA, on the other hand likes the more showy approach. Each to their own.

Well, maybe, but the greater influence on my suggestion is that male teachers wore jackets and ties when I was in school. The teachers in my daughters' school wear ties and the administrators wear suits. I think the jacket and tie are appropriate.

[Highland Logan]

I mean no offence here, but Bob's answer clearly demonstrates the difference between how I perceive you Americans see things and how us Scots see things. We Scots prefer the low profile "less is more " approach, Bob, batting for the USA, on the other hand likes the more showy approach. Each to their own.

Well, maybe, but the greater influence on my suggestion is that male teachers wore jackets and ties when I was in school. The teachers in my daughters' school wear ties and the administrators wear suits. I think the jacket and tie are appropriate.

I think you are missing Jock Scot' point. He was fine with a jacket and tie... but a plain tweed day dress jacket, not a black barathea Argyll with the silver buttons, which is somewhat the equivalent of morning dress, and very flashy.

Frank

[Bob C]

I think you are missing Jock Scot' point. He was fine with a jacket and tie... but a plain tweed day dress jacket, not a black barathea Argyll with the silver buttons, which is somewhat the equivalent of morning dress, and very flashy.

Frank

If you read my earlier post, you will see that that would be my preference, as well.